Difference between revisions of ".Mjkz.MjQ3NA"

From DigitalMaine Transcription Project
Jump to: navigation, search
(Created page with "an atmosp}Jere of truth and bring · This fmnk Indictment was folhis characters to lite. To Illustrate lowed by equally hearty commenhis point, he recounted a fascinatdation o...")
 
 
Line 1: Line 1:
an atmosp}Jere of truth and bring ·
+
an atmosphere of truth and bring his characters to life. To illustrate his point, he recounted a fascinat-ing story of technique developed in connection with certain events in one of his recent books. From some retreat, instantly reached, he drew fourth a ten-page letter and draw-ings of some size, which, he ex-plained, were made by an American naval officer to convice him that he was wrong in certain descriptions of the Battle of Valcour Is-land.
This fmnk Indictment was folhis characters to lite. To Illustrate
+
"The face is that this ex-naval of-ficer has not worked hard enough to obtain his information. He has taken it from histories, and most histories are wrong.  To get correct information for 'Rabble" I dug it from the Canadian archives and the British Admiralty, but since I am a novelist and not an historian I find it rather difficult, not to say embarrassing, to convince some people that I am as good as I'd like to have them believe."
lowed by equally hearty commenhis point, he recounted a fascinatdation of the way history Is being
+
Here Mr. Roberts cited the mys-tery of General Burgoyne's mis-tress, the woman whose charms delayed Burgoyne's retreat from Saratoga so long that disaster over-took his army. Historians were con-tent to state that the woman was wife of a commissary. Their posi-tion was based on the say-so of Baroness Riedesel, whose writings became their authority. Mr. Rob-erts, however, had to know who she was, since she promised, at one time, to become a character in 'Rabble in Arms'.
ing story of technique developed in
+
"I asked Milton Lord, director of the Boston public library, who best could help me in this research.  He referred me to Zoltan Haraszty, head of the rare manuscripts de-partment of the Boston public li-brary, Mr. Haraszty dug out the list of the seven commissaries attached to the British army. By the clever-est of literary detective work, he found out the one commissary to whose wife Burgoyne could have had access. The only question then to be decided was whether or not the Baroness had lied.  Historical research, you see, is very simple, once you know how to do it!"
taught at Exeter Academy.
+
Another factor essential to truth in writing historical novels, he pointed out, is application of data to what is known from one's own life experience.  To illustrate this point, Mr. Roberts referred to the universally accepted statement, made by General St. Clair in his courtmartial, that there was a bright moon during the retreat of the American army from Ticonderoga in 1777.
connection with certain event., in
+
"When I applied this statement to my own experiences," said he. "I knew that if the moon was full the retreating Americans would have been seen and attacked by the British. They were not, however Why not?  Either the British were crazy, or St. Clair was mistaken about the moon. I got a calendar for 1777 and found that on the date in question there was a new moon.  A new moon sets before darkness shuts down.  Therefore there had not been a moon that night, after all.  St. Clair unconsciously lied. But historians have accepted the lie ever since.  Most historians have mistaken their calling!  They should have been novelists or plumbers!"
"I can pull down from library
+
This frank indictment was fol-lowed by equally hearty commen-dation of the way history is being taught at Exeter Academy.
one of his recent books. From some
+
"I can pull down from library shelves hundreds of histories crammed with the grossest inac-curacies and half-truths.  until re-cently such inaccuracies were tak-en as gospel in our school histories. But it is impossible  to teach the true from the false, and Exeter is doing it."
shelves
+
"How about source material?" was asked, the writer having in mind a reason given by Hugh Pen-dexter,  the Norway author of his-torical novels of the West and Middle West, as to why he had not chosen Maine for a background for his work. He had said that he had not contracted adequate source material, and intimated that it seemed limited.
hundreds
+
"At first I had many difficul-ties," said Mr. Roberts. "I had to learn how to find these sources. Now I know.  All you have to do is to enlist the help of the Congres-sional library, the Maine State li-brary, a couple of Senators, three or four rare book-dealers in Lon-don, a score of the best rare-cook dealers in Boston, Albany, Port-land, New York and Philadelphia, and employ research workers and photostatters to find and photo-graph long-lost manuscripts in England's public record office.
of
+
"Once you know the ropes it is simplicity itself--tho it would be easier if days were 48 hours long, instead of 24," he added with vigor.
histories
+
"What are you writing now?" came the farewell query, no small amount of the author's preclous morning work-period having been consumed.
retreat, instantly reached, he drew
+
There was no vestige of inertia, as Mr. Roberts turned back to his desk, preparatory to finishing the sentence he had been writing two hours previous. His evergy and zest seem unlimited.
crammed with th e grossest Inacforth a ten-page letter and drawcuracies and half-truths. Untll reings of some size, which, he excently such Inaccuracies were takplained, were made by an American
+
"I have been working on a long novel ina New England setting, to cover a period from 1759 tp 1780.  Much of the action is laid in Kit-tery and Portsmouth, tho it moves to England, the Great Lakes re-gion, and perhaps to Algiers be-fore it is done.
en e.s gospel Ip our school histories.
+
"Will it be finished this year?" was rather an over-anxious ques-tion, speaking for admirers of his productions.
naval officer to convince him that
+
"No," he replied, "I've worked a year on it already, and it will take another year, at least."
But It is Impossible to tea.ch the
+
Mr. Roberts said that on all hiss books he had had the advice and assistance of Booth Tarkington, a neighbor at Kennebunk. Mr. Rob-erts considers him the greatest lit-erary craftsman writing in the English language today.
he was wrong In certain descriptrue from the false, and Exeter ts
+
"A lot of so-called great writers have been turned up in the past decade," he said, "but by compari-son with Tarkington they are jokes."
tions of the Battle of Valcour Isdoing it."
+
It was interesting to find that Mr. Roberts insists that novels about people of New England are a s untrue as they are full, if the characters are grim, sour and aus-tere.
land.
+
"I've gunned with Maine people and fished with Maine people and lived among Maine people all my life. They are witty and they are amusing. One can't leave out the humor of our people and our people and be true to life, tho some authors have done it and have been acclaimed for it.  The humor of our New Englanders is as good as any humor in the world!" he concluded.
"How about source material?"
+
In the hot sun outside fountain waters were dancing, and roses and pansies were delicately fragrant.
was asked, the writer having In
+
From the house, modestly set among densely shading trees just across the narrow roadway, em-erged Mrs. Roberts and a guest, ready for their ocean bath; and with a quick change of mind Mr. Roberts suddenly joined them.
"The fact I& that this ex-naval ofmind a r eason given by Hugh Penficer had not worked hard enough
+
One leaves such a place reluc-tantly--there are so many things of interest from far corners of the world.  But the Roberts' family seem entrenched in Maine.  They'll be here on the coast year after year, continuingly hopeful that the beauty to which they were born and for which they have such a profound regard will be enhanced by wiser methods of conservation and development.
dexter, the Norway author of histo obtain his Information. He had
+
So may it be!
torical novels of the West and
 
taken it from histories, and most
 
Middle West, as to why he had not
 
histories are wrong. To get correct
 
chosen Me.lne for a background for
 
information for 'Rabble' I dug It
 
his work. He had said that he had
 
from the Canadian archives and
 
not contracted adequate source
 
the British Admiralty, but since I
 
materla!, and intimated that It
 
am a novellst and not an historian
 
seemed limited.
 
I find It rather difficult, not to say
 
"At first I had many difficulembarrassing, to convince
 
some
 
ties," said Mr. Roberts. "I had to
 
people that I am as good as I'd like
 
learn how to find th ese sources.
 
to have them belleve."
 
Now I know. All you have to do !~
 
Here Mr. Roberts cited the mysto enlist the h elp of the Congrestery of General Burgoyne's missional library, the Maine State 11·
 
tress, the woman whose charma
 
brary, a couple of ·senators, three
 
delayed Burgoyne's retreat from
 
or four rare book-dealers in LonSaratoga so long that disaster overdon, a score of the b est rare-book
 
took his army. Historians were condealers In Boston, Albany, Porttent to state that the woman was
 
land, New York and Philadelphia,
 
wife of a commissary. Their posie.nd employ research workers and
 
tion was based on the say-so of
 
Baroness Riedesel, whose writings
 
I photostatters to tlnd and photobecame their authority. Mr. Robgraph long-lost
 
manuscripts In
 
erts, however, had to know who she
 
England's public record office.
 
was, since she promised, a.t one
 
"Once you know the ropes it is
 
slmpllcity itself-tho It would be
 
t~e, ~ecome ;_ character In
 
easier If days were -48 hours long,
 
'Rabble in Arms'.
 
Instead of 24," he added with vigor.
 
"I asked Milton Lord, director of
 
"What are you writing now?"
 
the Boston public library, who best
 
came the farewell query, no small
 
could help me In this research. He
 
11mount of the author's precious
 
referred me to Zoltan Haraszty,
 
morning work-period having been
 
head of the rare manuscripts deconsumed.
 
partment of the Boston public 1!There was no vestige ot Inertia,
 
brary, Mr. Haraszty aug out the list
 
as Mr. Roberts turned back to hie
 
of the seven ·commissaries attached
 
desk, preparatory to finishing the
 
to the British army, By the cleversentence he had been writing two
 
est of literary detective work, he
 
hours previous. His energy and
 
found out the one commissary to
 
~est seem unlimited.
 
,
 
whose wife Burgoyne could have
 
"I have been working on a long
 
had access. The only que6tlon then
 
novel in a New England setting, to
 
to be decided was whether or not
 
cover a period from 17°69 to 1780.
 
the Baroness had lied. Historical
 
Much of the action Is laid in Kitresearch, you see, Is very simple,
 
tery and Portsmouth, tho it moves
 
once you know how to do lt!"
 
to England, the Great Lakes reAnother factor esse.ntlal to truth
 
gion, and perhaps to Algiers beIn writing historical novels, he
 
fore it is done.
 
pointed out, Is appllcation of data
 
"Will It be finished t!hls year?"
 
to what ts known from one's own
 
was rather an over-anxious queslite experience. To illustrate this
 
tion, speaking tor admirers of his
 
point, Mr. Roberts referred to the
 
productions.
 
universally aceepted
 
statement,
 
"No," he replled. "I've worked a
 
_
 
made l,.y Genera.I St. Clair In his
 
year on It already, and It w!ll take
 
another year, at lea.st."
 
courtmartial, that there was a
 
Mr. Roberts said that on all his
 
br~ht moon during the retreat of
 
books he has had the advice and
 
the American army from Ticonderassistance of Booth Tarkington, a
 
oga In 1777.
 
neighbor at Kennebunk. Mr. Rob"When I appUed this statement
 
erts considers him the greatest litto my own experiences," said he.
 
erary craftsman writing in the
 
"I knew that If the moon was full
 
English language today.
 
the retreating Americans would
 
"A lot of so-caUed great writers
 
have been seen and attacked by the
 
have been turned up In the past
 
British. They were not, however.
 
decade," he said, "but by compariWhy not? Either the British were
 
son with Tarkington they are
 
crazy, or St. Clair was mistaken
 
jokes."
 
...bout the moon. I got a calendar
 
It was interesting to find that
 
tor 1777 and found that on the date
 
Mr. Roberts insists that novels
 
In. question there was a new moon.
 
about people of New England are
 
A Dew moon sets before darkness
 
as untrue as they are dull, if the
 
shuts down. Therefore there had
 
characters are grim, sour and ausnot been a moon that night. after
 
tere.
 
au. St. Clair unconsciously lied.
 
But historians have accepted the lie
 
ever since. Most blstorians have
 
mistaken
 
their
 
caW,ng!
 
They
 
should have been
 
nO\'ellsts or
 
plumbers!"
 
 
 
I
 
 
 
I
 
 
 
"I've gunned with Maine people
 
and fished with Malne people and
 
lived among Maine people aJI my
 
life. They are w'!tty and they are
 
i amusing. One can't leave out the
 
I humor of our people and be true
 
to llfe, tho some authors have done
 
It and have been acclaimed for It.
 
The humor of our New Englander•
 
Is as good as any humor In the
 
world!" he concluded.
 
In the hot sun outside fountain
 
waters were dancing, and roses and
 
pansies were dellcately fragrant.
 
From the house, modestly set
 
among densely shading trees just
 
across the narrow roadway, emerged Mrs. Roberts and a guest.
 
ready for their ocean bath; and
 
with a quick change of mind M:r.
 
Roberts suddenly joined them.
 
I One leaves such a place reluctantly-there are so many things
 
of Interest from far corners of the
 
world. But the Roberts' family
 
seem entrenched In Maine. They'll
 
be here on the coast year after ·
 
year, contlnu!ngly hopeful that the
 
beauty to which they were born
 
and for which they .have such a
 
profound regard will be enhanc~d
 
by wiser methods of conservation
 
a.nd development.
 
So ma:v it be!
 
 
 
I
 
 
 
I
 
 
 
I
 
 
 
 

Latest revision as of 00:22, 28 March 2017

an atmosphere of truth and bring his characters to life. To illustrate his point, he recounted a fascinat-ing story of technique developed in connection with certain events in one of his recent books. From some retreat, instantly reached, he drew fourth a ten-page letter and draw-ings of some size, which, he ex-plained, were made by an American naval officer to convice him that he was wrong in certain descriptions of the Battle of Valcour Is-land. "The face is that this ex-naval of-ficer has not worked hard enough to obtain his information. He has taken it from histories, and most histories are wrong. To get correct information for 'Rabble" I dug it from the Canadian archives and the British Admiralty, but since I am a novelist and not an historian I find it rather difficult, not to say embarrassing, to convince some people that I am as good as I'd like to have them believe." Here Mr. Roberts cited the mys-tery of General Burgoyne's mis-tress, the woman whose charms delayed Burgoyne's retreat from Saratoga so long that disaster over-took his army. Historians were con-tent to state that the woman was wife of a commissary. Their posi-tion was based on the say-so of Baroness Riedesel, whose writings became their authority. Mr. Rob-erts, however, had to know who she was, since she promised, at one time, to become a character in 'Rabble in Arms'. "I asked Milton Lord, director of the Boston public library, who best could help me in this research. He referred me to Zoltan Haraszty, head of the rare manuscripts de-partment of the Boston public li-brary, Mr. Haraszty dug out the list of the seven commissaries attached to the British army. By the clever-est of literary detective work, he found out the one commissary to whose wife Burgoyne could have had access. The only question then to be decided was whether or not the Baroness had lied. Historical research, you see, is very simple, once you know how to do it!" Another factor essential to truth in writing historical novels, he pointed out, is application of data to what is known from one's own life experience. To illustrate this point, Mr. Roberts referred to the universally accepted statement, made by General St. Clair in his courtmartial, that there was a bright moon during the retreat of the American army from Ticonderoga in 1777. "When I applied this statement to my own experiences," said he. "I knew that if the moon was full the retreating Americans would have been seen and attacked by the British. They were not, however Why not? Either the British were crazy, or St. Clair was mistaken about the moon. I got a calendar for 1777 and found that on the date in question there was a new moon. A new moon sets before darkness shuts down. Therefore there had not been a moon that night, after all. St. Clair unconsciously lied. But historians have accepted the lie ever since. Most historians have mistaken their calling! They should have been novelists or plumbers!" This frank indictment was fol-lowed by equally hearty commen-dation of the way history is being taught at Exeter Academy. "I can pull down from library shelves hundreds of histories crammed with the grossest inac-curacies and half-truths. until re-cently such inaccuracies were tak-en as gospel in our school histories. But it is impossible to teach the true from the false, and Exeter is doing it." "How about source material?" was asked, the writer having in mind a reason given by Hugh Pen-dexter, the Norway author of his-torical novels of the West and Middle West, as to why he had not chosen Maine for a background for his work. He had said that he had not contracted adequate source material, and intimated that it seemed limited. "At first I had many difficul-ties," said Mr. Roberts. "I had to learn how to find these sources. Now I know. All you have to do is to enlist the help of the Congres-sional library, the Maine State li-brary, a couple of Senators, three or four rare book-dealers in Lon-don, a score of the best rare-cook dealers in Boston, Albany, Port-land, New York and Philadelphia, and employ research workers and photostatters to find and photo-graph long-lost manuscripts in England's public record office. "Once you know the ropes it is simplicity itself--tho it would be easier if days were 48 hours long, instead of 24," he added with vigor. "What are you writing now?" came the farewell query, no small amount of the author's preclous morning work-period having been consumed. There was no vestige of inertia, as Mr. Roberts turned back to his desk, preparatory to finishing the sentence he had been writing two hours previous. His evergy and zest seem unlimited. "I have been working on a long novel ina New England setting, to cover a period from 1759 tp 1780. Much of the action is laid in Kit-tery and Portsmouth, tho it moves to England, the Great Lakes re-gion, and perhaps to Algiers be-fore it is done. "Will it be finished this year?" was rather an over-anxious ques-tion, speaking for admirers of his productions. "No," he replied, "I've worked a year on it already, and it will take another year, at least." Mr. Roberts said that on all hiss books he had had the advice and assistance of Booth Tarkington, a neighbor at Kennebunk. Mr. Rob-erts considers him the greatest lit-erary craftsman writing in the English language today. "A lot of so-called great writers have been turned up in the past decade," he said, "but by compari-son with Tarkington they are jokes." It was interesting to find that Mr. Roberts insists that novels about people of New England are a s untrue as they are full, if the characters are grim, sour and aus-tere. "I've gunned with Maine people and fished with Maine people and lived among Maine people all my life. They are witty and they are amusing. One can't leave out the humor of our people and our people and be true to life, tho some authors have done it and have been acclaimed for it. The humor of our New Englanders is as good as any humor in the world!" he concluded. In the hot sun outside fountain waters were dancing, and roses and pansies were delicately fragrant. From the house, modestly set among densely shading trees just across the narrow roadway, em-erged Mrs. Roberts and a guest, ready for their ocean bath; and with a quick change of mind Mr. Roberts suddenly joined them. One leaves such a place reluc-tantly--there are so many things of interest from far corners of the world. But the Roberts' family seem entrenched in Maine. They'll be here on the coast year after year, continuingly hopeful that the beauty to which they were born and for which they have such a profound regard will be enhanced by wiser methods of conservation and development. So may it be!